How to Feed Your Picky Eater Cat

How to Handle Cats that are Picky Eaters

It wouldn’t be the first time that a cat is being picky about their food. It seems to be a pretty universal experience: your cat turning up their nose at the food you’ve just put in their bowl. Rest assured, you’re definitely not the first cat owner that this has happened to. Cats have a reputation for being single-minded, independent and choosy. That makes cats picky or fussy eaters by nature. Find out how to stay on top of their fickle habits as we look at ways you can keep your fussy cat fed, happy and healthy.

Reasons Why Cats Can Be Picky Eaters

So what’s the reason for a cat’s picky eating? Don’t immediately assume stubbornness on the cat’s part, there’s a long list of reasons behind their lackluster eating habits, especially if their appetite has recently changed.

If your cat has shown no interest in food for more than a day, that, in itself, can lead to serious complications. It’s always best to consult your vet if there’s a sudden change in appetite that seemingly comes out of the blue. First? Please rule out any medical conditions before proceeding onward.

Medical and Environmental Factors

When you’re dealing with a picky eater cat, it’s important to rule out a medical condition first. These are some of the most common medical conditions that could be the root cause of their behavior:

  1. Upper respiratory infections
  2. Fever and nausea from gastrointestinal disease
  3. Kidney or liver disease
  4. Pancreatitis, dental or oral pain and diabetes
  5. Trauma injuries and cancer

If your cat isn’t eating, your vet may refer to the condition as anorexia. The term has different connotations in cats compared to humans and simply means loss of appetite. There could be one or more several environmental factors at play too, stress in particular.

If your pet is an outdoor cat, there is always the chance they’ll take a wander into a neighbor’s home to see if they have something more tasty on offer. It’s a problem that’s almost impossible to control. You could try printing a collar that says, ‘Do not feed me!’

Cat insurance from From Dog insurance from Coverage Contribution Own risk
petsecur logo €8.46 €12.11 €3.250 — €6.000 10% — 50% €0 — €150
per year
ohra logo €14.05 €17.77 €3.000 — €6.000 20% €30 — €50
per year
figopet logo €12.16 €17.42 €3.000 — €5.000 20% — 50% €0 — €250
per year
InShared logo €13.27 €20,14 €3.000 — €6.000 20% none View
Unive logo €13.86 €14.67 €2.500 — €5.000 20% none View
aegon logo €10.56 €13.14 €3.500 25% €25
per claim

Tips on how to feed your Picky Eating Cats

The first step to nipping the picky-eating habits of adult cats in the bud is to establish a routine for meals. Stick to the feeding regime consistently each day and at one or two specific times. If you allow your cat to “free-feed” or alter their regular meal pattern, this could disrupt their eating habits. The result? Your picky cat turning down its next meal.

Try to use treats as rewards only when training your cat in certain behaviors. If you throw in tasty tit-bits whenever it suits you, your cat will learn to try and hold out for something better than what’s in their bowl.

You could, however, try using food puzzles as a way to get your cat to eat more. These encourage cats to move around for their food. They are good options for indoor cats who both have a higher risk of obesity and also require more environmental stimulation from their owners. Talk to your vet about potential options.

Cats only have a few hundred taste buds. That compares to many thousands in humans. They tend not to be able to differentiate sweet-tasting foods, for example, but most love fat. It’s possible that their heightened sense of smell makes up for their poor taste.

Location and Cleanliness

Some cats prefer eating alone without anyone else watching them. Place your cat’s bowl in a quiet and peaceful place. Other cats might only eat when you stroke them gently or hand feed them.

Keep your cat’s bowl clean. Wash it after every use to prevent the growth of harmful bacteria. Rinse the bowl off thoroughly to avoid any residue from your detergent getting left on the bowl. The smell of it can put cats off. Use a metal or ceramic bowl and avoid plastic varieties.

If your cat typically enjoys dry food but suddenly becomes a picky eater, it might be time to replace your food supply. Dry food absorbs moisture so if you live somewhere with high humidity, your stocks may turn stale more quickly.

Temperature and Multi-Cat Households

The temperature of the food may also be an issue. For example, wet food can lose its tasty smell if you keep it in the fridge. Try warming any chilled food you have in a microwave for a few seconds until it gets to room temperature.

Your cat may also suffer a loss of appetite if the weather’s too hot for them. 

If you have several cats in your home, ensure there are sufficient food bowls so that each cat has their own. Keep the bowls well-spaced from each other. This helps to reduce stress and any sense of competing at mealtimes.

Changing Your Cat’s Food

If all else fails, you should consider changing your cat’s food. This might also be your vet’s preferred option if they feel a medical condition might benefit from a change in diet. The key is to take things slowly.

Continue serving what they’ve become used to, but gradually mix in the new food over a period of a week to 10 days. This helps to prevent bouts of diarrhea or vomiting that can happen with a sudden change in diet.

To make the food more appetizing, you could try:

  • Adding a little warmed, low-salt chicken broth to their bowl
  • Put some meat marketed as baby food on top of their normal food
  • Mix in some oil or brine from a can of tuna or anchovies

If you have problems delivering your cat’s medication in food, talk to your vet about possible non-oral treatments. When you continually try to hide pills or medicine in the food of a picky cat, you might put them off their regular food even more.

If your cat appears otherwise in good health but struggles to eat, they may have a dental issue that makes mealtimes difficult and painful. Check your cat’s gums for signs of redness or swelling and, if necessary, make an appointment to see your vet.

Get Advice From Your Vet

If your cat’s a fussy or picky eater and you can’t figure out why, talk to us for reassurance and more top tips. We always have a vet on hand to help whatever the situation.

You can find lots of other valuable articles related to keeping your cat healthy and happy here in our blog section. We also have a variety of very competitive pet insurance products on offer. A video consultation with one of Cooper Pet Care’s qualified veterinarians is only a few clicks away. Fast, simple, and secure – get the answers you need.

Looking for answers for
your furry friend?

Use our automatic Symptom Checker for advice on what to do next.

  • Answer questions about the issue to narrow down options
  • Wide range of symptoms and answers
  • Information on the most common toxic foods and household items
What seems to be the problem?
My dog Lily has vomited
Is there blood in the vomit?
Check Symptoms Now